Tower Survives Greatly Exaggerated Rumors and
Prepares to Reopen
By SUSAN
SAULNY
October 17, 2001
One Liberty Plaza, the sleek black skyscraper just east of the World
Trade Center, was the subject of numerous reports of collapse and serious
structural damage in the hours and days just after Sept. 11. Rumors of its
demise, however, were premature. The building is reopening, with a
celebration scheduled for Monday. A ribbon will be cut at the 54-story
building, which has arguably been pronounced "structurally sound" more times
than any other skyscraper in the city.
"There are no structural concerns with this building," said Ilyse Fink, the
director of communications for the city's Department of Buildings,
reinforcing a message she has delivered almost daily since Sept. 12. "It is
not and was not in danger of collapse. The building is structurally sound."
What scares many of those who will be moving back has nothing to do with
structural integrity. It has to do with the emotion of doing business in
offices practically atop ground zero. The building's lobby was an emergency
triage center on the night of the attacks, and one of its stores was a
makeshift morgue. The building is directly across Church Street from the
trade center's rubble.
"I think that most of us are absolutely prepared to believe that if the
building owners, engineers and other powers that be tell us the building is
safe, it's safe," said Pam Sloan, a partner with Flemming, Zulack and
Williamson, a law firm on the 35th floor. "Reservations have to do with the
fear of feeling this profound sadness by being so close. Among my
colleagues, that's the biggest concern.
"No one wants to feel that," she continued. "We're almost afraid to feel
that, and it's going to be right there. Emotionally, I think this will be
very difficult."
The building's management company, Brookfield Financial Properties, is
gauging what occupancy will be after the attacks. The chief executive of
Brookfield, Richard B. Clark, said he recognized that "a number of firms
that had to take temporary space have the latitude to take their time before
coming back." He added, "I think it will take a month or so before people
come back in."
But no firm "has said for sure that they're not coming back," he said. "No
one has said that for certain yet."
While no tenant may have released plans about a move, a persistent problem
downtown is that many firms have not decided yet, or have not announced
their intentions, according to an online brokerage firm that specializes in
downtown office space, TenantWise.com.
According to M. Myers Mermel, the chief executive of TenantWise.com,
a number of firms at 1 Liberty Plaza may fall into this category.
Mr. Mermel said he concluded from his surveys that only 12 percent of
tenants who leased more than 10,000 square feet of space in destroyed or
damaged buildings had committed to returning to Lower Manhattan.
That might be because the logistics of working so close to ground zero
present their own set of challenges.
Allen Kaye, an immigration lawyer who had offices on the 23rd floor of 1
Liberty Plaza, is temporarily operating from Midtown and said he might like
to stay farther up the island. "I've been downtown for 20 years," he said.
"There's always been a difference in uptown and downtown cultures, but now
it's like a war zone down there, with tourists gawking with cameras and
policemen everywhere. It's all very spooky."
Before Sept. 11, Mr. Kaye decided to move to another downtown building, on
Broadway. He was in temporary space at 1 Liberty Plaza. Now he is
reconsidering downtown altogether. "I've been down to Liberty Plaza twice,
both times with a police escort and through a freight elevator," Mr. Kaye
said. "I'm wondering, do my clients need a police escort?"
Among the buildings in the area, 1 Liberty Plaza was unusual because of the
numerous erroneous news reports, including one broadcast on CNN, that the
building had collapsed. In fact, the building also had its own rumor mill
and its own running joke, which made its way up from the street all the way
to the Department of Buildings: "Oops, Liberty Plaza just collapsed again."
But just about the only kinds of repairs that the building needed were the
replacement of hundreds of windows that had been blown out on its western
facade and the removal of heavy dust and debris.
But now, issues about access are still being worked through, Mr. Clark said.
"Clearly, it won't be as good as before Sept. 11," he said, noting that the
Church Street entrance will be closed for months. "But we think under the
circumstances, it will not be bad. Having had the opportunity to go down
there, I see progress and positive things myself."