City and state officials announced yesterday that a university, a
department store and three law firms were among 14 companies to receive
nearly $33 million in federal grants intended to revitalize Lower
Manhattan's economy.
The grants represent the first round of an effort to keep major employers
downtown and to attract new companies to Lower Manhattan — which has been
wracked by layoffs on Wall Street, corporate relocations and transportation
problems since Sept. 11 — Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg and Gov. George E.
Pataki said at a news conference at City Hall. The 14 employers, which
represent a combined total of 10,272 jobs, have committed themselves to
remaining downtown for seven years or more.
"Because large companies employ more than half of the private jobs in Lower
Manhattan, the stabilization of these corporations is essential," Mr.
Bloomberg said. "These employers will revitalize the downtown community by
restoring confidence in the area, stabilizing the job base, and providing
needed foot traffic to small businesses."
It is unlikely that the employers — Pace University, the Century 21
department store, Deloitte & Touche, Brown Brothers Harriman & Company, the
law firm of Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson or any of the nine
other firms awarded the grants yesterday — were even thinking about leaving
Lower Manhattan. Most of them have long-term leases for office space in
buildings that escaped damage from the terrorist attack last September. The
biggest single grant, $13 million, went to Deloitte & Touche.
But city and state officials are hoping to create a sense of momentum in the
reconstruction effort downtown. They also want to restore confidence in the
viability of the district and make it easier to hammer out deals with other
companies and lure new business to the area.
The next round of companies, however, may prove to be far more difficult to
nail down. The Bank of New York, for instance, is moving back to 101 Barclay
St., but is planning to transfer some employees to Jersey City or the
Atlantic Terminal area, in Brooklyn. AIG, the giant insurance company that
is one of the largest downtown employers, is considering moving as many as
1,500 workers to Jersey City or to Brooklyn, according to real estate
executives.
Aon, the insurance company, which had its offices in the World Trade Center,
is still looking for a home, possibly at 55 Water Street or 75 Wall Street.
Many companies are reluctant to sign deals committing them to keeping a
specific number of employees downtown, said real estate executives and
lawyers, although they certainly would want subsidies to move technical and
database operations to Brooklyn or Long Island City.
"There's no question that there are more complicated cases than some of
those we signed up today," said Deputy Mayor Daniel Doctoroff. "Our goal is
to have every single company sign up and commit to staying in Lower
Manhattan. We're beginning to see a snowballing of confidence."
The other employers whose grants were announced today are Ambac Financial
Group; Bank of Nova Scotia; Deloitte Consulting; Holland & Knight, a law
firm; Hughes Hubbard & Reed, another law firm; Media Planning Group; Nomura
Holding America; Refco Group, a financial firm, and Wildcat Service
Corporation, which does job training. The money is part of $700 million in
community development block grants from the federal Department of Housing
and Urban Development.
Mr. Doctoroff said that the city and the state decided early on to offer
benefit packages to all 145 companies in Lower Manhattan that have more than
200 employees. Those at risk of leaving the city may get more than others,
he said.
The mayor and the governor, who are both Republicans, were joined at the
news conference by three Democrats, Senators Charles Schumer and Hillary
Clinton and State Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, who all congratulated
each other on cooperating on downtown reconstruction.
Bettina Damiani, director of Good Jobs New York, a private foundation, said
that public officials should also invest in job training for thousands of
hotel workers, clerks, mechanics and others affected by the disaster.
"Future funds need to be used to develop coordinated job training and
industry development," she said. "They need to address the 75,000 low-wage
workers who lost their jobs."
After 2,800 people died at the trade center and more than 13 million square
feet of office space was destroyed, some financial firms, like Lehman
Brothers, decided to abandon downtown, while many others sought to disperse
their operations.
American Express and Merrill Lynch have moved back to the World Financial
Center, although hundreds of workers at both companies have been laid off.
As a result, the vacancy rate in downtown office buildings has soared to 17
percent, from 4 percent two years ago, according to TenantWise.com, a
commercial real estate broker.
"This is clearly a step in the right direction," said M. Myers Mermel,
chief executive of TenantWise. "But the economy continues to exacerbate
a soft real estate market created by the flight of tenants from Lower
Manhattan post 9/11."
Raymond Gindi, the chief operating officer of Century 21, which employs
1,000 people at its store at 22 Cortlandt Street, said he was glad to see
the grant money. The store, which was damaged in the collapse of the twin
towers, reopened two months ago. The street in front of the store is still
closed to traffic, he said, and business is still off. He is hoping to
survive until nearby subway and PATH train stations are rebuilt.
"We're appreciative of what we're getting," Mr. Gindi said, "but we need all
the help we can get."