On Manhattan's Far West Side, Stadium and
Convention Center Stir Dreams, Fears
By KAREN MATTHEWS, Associated Press Writer
February 14, 2004
NEW YORK -- It's been called the final frontier _ a big chunk of
Manhattan's West Side consisting mainly of warehouses, auto body shops and
old railroad yards.
Now there's new momentum for a long-discussed scheme to transform the
neighborhood with new office towers overlooking the Hudson River, a vast
convention center and a riverfront stadium for the New York Jets _ and
possibly the 2012 Olympics.
Just this past week, officials announced preliminary details for $2.77
billion worth of infrastructure improvements, including a subway extension,
and for an expansion of the area's 18-year-old Jacob K. Javits Convention
Center.
But the West Side will not be won over easily.
Local activists oppose the plan, saying such extensive development will
destroy a neighborhood also known for its shops, taverns and human-scale
housing. And some development experts question whether the demand for office
space will ever meet the city's ambitious predictions.
"If the city goes forward with these plans, there will be lawsuits filed,"
said Assemblyman Richard Gottfried, whose district includes the proposed
redevelopment zone. He said his constituents are "overwhelmingly opposed to
a stadium as well as to the city's development plan."
Since 1984, the Jets have played at the home stadium of the New York Giants
in East Rutherford, N.J. Before that, they played at Shea Stadium from
1964-83, where they shared with the New York Mets.
Getting a stadium of its own has been a focus of the organization since
owner Woody Johnson bought the team in 2000.
Returning to New York also is important to the franchise. The far West Side
extends from roughly Eighth Avenue westward to the Hudson River and from
28th Street to 42nd Street.
The Jets have been promoting a stadium in the area with a retractable dome
for the past year. No financing plan has been announced for the $1.5 billion
project, but public speculation has suggested the city and state could kick
in about $600 million.
Jets President L. Jay Cross said moving to Manhattan from New Jersey's
Meadowlands makes sense because 70 percent of fans would use public
transportation. "Every week that we play (at the Meadowlands) we force
30,000 cars onto the road, and that's not necessarily a good thing," Cross
said.
The stadium also is a key component in the city's bid to host the summer
Olympics in 2012. The city will have to show some progress toward building a
stadium by the time the International Olympic Committee announces a choice
in July 2005.
Business leaders spelled out plans Thursday to add thousands of square feet
of convention space to the glass-walled Javits Center. The plan would cost
an estimated $1.5 billion to $1.7 billion just for the first of two phases,
said Charles Gargano, chairman of the Empire State Development Corp.
New York officials have long complained that the Javits Center lacks the
space to attract the biggest conventions. At 814,000 square feet, it ranks
14th among the nation's convention centers. The biggest is Chicago's
McCormick Place, with more than 2 million square feet.
Daniel Doctoroff, the city's deputy mayor for economic development, cited a
report prepared by real estate giant Cushman & Wakefield that estimated the
metropolitan region will need 110 million square feet of new office space
between 2005 and 2025.
Others say that projection is too optimistic.
M. Myers Mermel, who operates the commercial real estate firm
Tenantwise, said the city's goal is unrealistic and would compete with
the rebirth of the World Trade Center in lower Manhattan.
"It should logically occur after lower Manhattan is redeveloped," he said.
But Steven Spinola, president of the Real Estate Board of New York, called
the plan terrific.
"It's probably the best planning the city has done, to my recollection," he
said. "It is thorough, it's thoughtful and it will really permit the city to
grow in the future and to be competitive."